

SRINAGAR/JAMMU: In nearly half of Jammu and Kashmir's assembly constituencies, the Election Commission of India (ECI) has no record of how many people voted in the last hour of polling in 2024, according to internal ECI records examined by The Reporters' Collective (TRC).
In the second part of its Election Audit series, TRC reports that in 44 of J&K's 90 assembly seats, the returning officers' reports carried no figure for votes polled after 5 pm. Polling was scheduled to close at 6 pm. The same gap appears in the Jammu Lok Sabha constituency.
The finding follows the first part, which showed that in nine J&K contests officials had entered "nil" or "0" for the number of voters who walked into polling booths. Seven of those nine seats turn up again in the new findings.
"The Election Commission of India is the custodian of our votes," TRC writes in the series. "When it turns blind, it should worry us all."
TRC reviewed the internal reports for 467 assembly and 63 parliamentary constituencies in Maharashtra, Haryana and J&K, all of which voted in 2024. Across the three, the after-5 pm record was missing in 200 of 530 seats.
Maharashtra has the most such seats in absolute terms, with 114. But J&K has the highest share. The record was missing in 44 of its 90 assembly seats, about 49 per cent, compared with about 40 per cent of Maharashtra's 288 seats and about 24 per cent of Haryana's 90.
Source: The Reporters' Collective, Election Audit Part 2. Shares rounded.
In the 2024 Lok Sabha election, the last-hour record is missing for 18 of Maharashtra's 48 parliamentary seats, one of Haryana's 10 and one of J&K's five. Venkatesh Nayak, the co-author of the TRC report told the Kashmir Times that the seat in question is Jammu, which was won by BJP’s Jugal Kishore Sharma.
The final hour of polling is the one most open to abuse. As TRC explains, experts say bogus voting is most likely late in the day, because many party polling agents, especially from weaker parties, have left the booths by then.
The ECI's own rules are designed to guard that hour. Every two hours, a booth's presiding officer presses the "Total" button on the EVM's control unit and records the number of votes cast in the Presiding Officer's Diary. That figure is checked against Form 17A, the Register of Voters, which another polling officer keeps separately as each voter walks in. The two counts should match at every check and at the close of poll.
When polling closes at 6 pm, the presiding officer hands numbered slips to everyone still in the queue, starting with the last person in line, and records how many slips were issued. Only slip holders may vote after closing time. TRC found that in 23 of the 530 seats, that slip count was not recorded either.
Seven of those 23 are in J&K: the Baramulla Lok Sabha seat, which Engineer Rashid won from jail in 2024 by defeating Omar Abdullah, and six assembly seats: Trehgam, Langate, Habbakadal, Devsar, Ramban and Jammu North. Trehgam, Habbakadal and Ramban lack both the last-hour figure and the slip count.
"These ECI reports are meant to act like a concurrent audit of the polls on the day of polling itself," former Election Commissioner Ashok Lavasa told TRC. Filling them in after the fact, he said, vitiates the mechanism meant to catch red flags.
TRC compares it to bookkeeping. Checking each transaction as it happens is an audit, while making entries at year's end to cover sham transactions is fraud. If the after-5 pm slot is left blank on the day and later made to fit the totals the ECI announces, TRC argues, fraudulent voting could slip through undetected.
TRC's data names the J&K constituencies. The gaps run across both regions, with Kashmir slightly ahead but revealing no stark divide. Of the 44 assembly seats without a last-hour record, 23 are in the Kashmir division, about half its 47 seats, and 21 in the Jammu division, about half its 43.
The slip counts follow the same pattern. Four of the six assembly seats without one (Trehgam, Langate, Habbakadal and Devsar) are in Kashmir and two (Ramban and Jammu North) in Jammu.
The two Lok Sabha gaps are split as well, Jammu missing its last-hour record and Baramulla its slip count. Whatever went wrong was not confined to one region, one district administration or the seats one party won.
Kashmir division (23): Karnah, Trehgam, Handwara, Rafiabad, Uri, Baramulla, Gulmarg, Gurez, Kangan, Ganderbal, Habbakadal, Lal Chowk, Zadibal, Eidgah, Budgam, Pulwama, Zainapora, Shopian, DH Pora, Kulgam, Dooru, Anantnag and Srigufwara-Bijbehara.
Jammu division (21): Ramban, Banihal, Gulabgarh, Chenani, Ramnagar, Basohli, Kathua, Hiranagar, Bishnah, Suchetgarh, RS Pura-Jammu South, Bahu, Jammu East, Jammu West, Marh, Akhnoor, Chhamb, Rajouri, Budhal, Poonch Haveli and Mendhar.
Some clusters stand out. Ganderbal and Budgam, the two seats Omar Abdullah contested and won in 2024, are both on the list. Budgam, which he later gave up, went to the PDP in last year's by-election. Four of Srinagar's eight seats are on it: Habbakadal, Lal Chowk, Zadibal and Eidgah.
In Jammu district, nine of 11 assembly seats lack the last-hour record, and a tenth, Jammu North, lacks the slip count. In the north, Baramulla, Uri, Rafiabad and Gulmarg are on the list from Baramulla district, alongside Karnah, Trehgam and Handwara in Kupwara.
TRC's starkest example is from Maharashtra. In Kopri-Pachpakhadi, Deputy Chief Minister Eknath Shinde's seat, polling was recorded only until 5 pm. Going by the ECI's own totals, 89,878 votes were cast in the last hour across 366 booths, or about four voters a minute at each booth. That would mean every voter was checked, signed in, inked and had voted within 15 seconds.
J&K, too, saw sizeable late-day jumps. In the third and final phase of the 2024 assembly election, on October 1, the ECI reported a turnout of 65.48 per cent at 5.00 PM. The final figure for that phase was 69.65 per cent. About half of the 44 seats, including the Jammu plains and much of north Kashmir, voted in that phase. Late surges are common and usually normal as queues form at the end of the day. But in seats where the last-hour record was never kept, the ECI has no booth-level evidence to show what happened in that hour.
Delays in J&K's count are nothing new. Those who covered elections here in earlier decades recall that, when communication links were weak, the last-hour figures from remote booths in the hills often took a day or two to reach district headquarters. When they arrived, the final tally barely moved. But the figures were always recorded, carried down by polling parties and entered in the records. That is what makes 2024 different: there is no record.
The new figures add to a pattern already visible in J&K. Part 1 of this investigation found that in nine J&K contests, including the Jammu parliamentary seat, Kishtwar, Shopian and Bandipora, officials recorded no walk-in voters at all. It also found that Srinagar's parliamentary seat counted more votes than were polled, and that Devsar in Kulgam was the only constituency among 531 whose returning officer's report TRC could not find.
The overlap is striking. Of the nine "nil" seats in Part 1, seven reappear in Part 2. The Jammu Lok Sabha seat and the assembly seats of Shopian, DH Pora, Zainapora, Rafiabad and Karnah are missing the last-hour record, and Jammu North is missing the slip count.
In the six that lack the last-hour record, the ECI's own files show neither who walked in to vote nor how many voted in the final hour. Only Kishtwar and Bandipora, two of the closest contests, do not reappear.
Devsar, the one seat whose returning officer's report TRC said it could not find, appears among the seats with no slip count.
TRC sent detailed questions to Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi, and the ECI's spokesperson, as well as to the chief electoral officers of Maharashtra, Haryana and J&K. The commission routed the questions to its Public Grievance Redressal System, asked TRC to supply the ECI's own data and promised to keep it confidential.
TRC says it will not file a "grievance" or communicate with the ECI in secret, and that it will publish all raw data and original ECI records with the final part of the series.
After Part 1, the ECI called the findings misleading and pointed to Form 17C and the index cards it publishes online. Lavasa, however, told TRC there should be no difference between the returning officer's report and the index cards, because the same officer prepares both.
This time the commission's offices in all three states, including J&K's chief electoral officer, issued rejoinders to Part 2. They rested on the same two documents, the index cards and Form 17C, which record the votes polled on the EVMs.
Sumedha Mittal, one of the series' authors, called the rejoinders misleading in a series of tweets on X, saying the ECI is "not telling the truth, and trying to cover up for its failures". Those documents, she pointed out, do not hold the two-hourly count. That count starts in the presiding officer's diary, which never reaches the ECI's headquarters. It is aggregated into the Report of the Returning Officer, the document TRC examined for all 530 seats. Where returning officers did their job, the reports show it. In Ghatkopar East in Maharashtra, the returning officer recorded two-hourly turnout broken down by gender.
"If the ECI's own officials skip the ECI's own process, how does the ECI expect to catch malpractice?" Mittal asked. The other possibility, she wrote, is that the commission does not scrutinise the reports its own officers submit, and that is the question it needs to answer.
The commission has also refused opposition requests for CCTV footage of after-5.00 PM polling. Defending that refusal, Kumar asked reporters whether the ECI should share footage of "our mothers, daughters-in-law and daughters".
TRC is explicit that it does not conclude whether, or where, voting was rigged. A missing figure may reflect sloppy paperwork rather than fraud. But the safeguard the ECI built to catch fraud on polling day was not used in these seats. The record that could have caught malpractice was never kept.
The ECI's position that its polling-day figures are only provisional makes the independent booth-level record more important, not less. Since 2019, the commission has stopped publishing booth-level data, and in December 2024 the election rules were amended to limit what the public can inspect.
The 2024 assembly election was J&K's first in a decade and its first since the abrogation of Article 370. It was widely celebrated for its turnout, and the National Conference took power on the strength of it. The mandate itself is not in question. What is in question is whether, in seat after seat, the ECI kept the records it needs to defend any result against challenge.
Several J&K contests were decided by narrow margins. Kishtwar went by 521 votes, Bandipora by 811 and Devsar by 840. Shopian, where the victory margin was 1,207 votes, now has gaps in both its walk-in and its last-hour record. Where margins are that thin and the paper trail is incomplete, neither the winner nor the loser can point to the ECI's own audit to settle a dispute.
The findings also arrive as protests against Kumar continue nationally over the voter-roll revision, and as the NC faces open dissent within its own ranks over whether it has delivered on the mandate it won.
TRC has said its raw data will be released at the end of the series. Kashmir Times will examine the J&K records when they are published.
What is still unknown
• How many votes were cast in the last hour in each of the 44 seats, and whether the ECI's final totals can be reconciled with the Presiding Officers' Diaries.
• Whether any J&K returning officer or presiding officer flagged the missing records at the time.
• Why Devsar's returning officer's report is missing, and why it is listed among seats with no slip count.
Have you liked the news article?
Support us now:
https://www.gofundme.com/manage/jammu-kashmirs-sole-independent-voice-under-threat