With a mounting death toll in floods across the subcontinent, and hundreds of thousands displaced, the numbers are not just statistics. They represent colossal loss and narrate the tale of a shared existential crisis.
Since the monsoon's onset on June 20, 2025, a cascade of intense hydro-meteorological events has pummeled South Asia. From the hills of Himachal Pradesh to the mountain valleys of Jammu and Kashmir, the paddy fields of Punjab and the forest villages of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, the story is the same: liquid chaos, scouring away not just crops, homes, and infrastructure, but the very fragile sense of security of millions.
This violent event is just one part of a much bigger, long-term disaster that connects South Asia's worst enemies. To understand what's happening, we need a multidisciplinary inquiry into the human condition at the precipice of collapse, hastened by our collective neglect of the environment, political intransigence and climatic fury.
For generations, the knowledge of the mountains was held in an ancient, localised lexicon: the language of the Sars (water bodies), the traditional water, streams, canals, the Khud and Nard (part of water bodies to mitigate floods), and the wetlands.
This was a deeply embedded, experiential study of nature, anchored in coexistence, and passed down through farmers and shepherds. It was a knowledge system that understood the land’s carrying capacity and its delicate rhythms, that has been systematically erased, often "eaten up by the mafia" in a brazen display of political-bureaucratic avarice and short-sighted, extractive logic.
In its place, ecologists now point to a new, terrifying lexicon of the Anthropocene: Glacial Lake Outburst Floods (GLOFs), cloudburst frequency, and the "bulging" of mountains due to dam reservoirs. This is one stark example of geological stress induced by human engineering, besides a phenomenal increase in the low intensity earthquakes, particularly in the upper Chenab Valley in recent years.
3,136 glaciers are fast melting in Jammu and Kashmir on either side of the Line of Control (LoC) and the Himalayan belt stands to lose around 15000, including the Siachen glaciers. These glaciers are not just ice turning to water, they are also burning down our climatic history and erasing ancient data we never fully learned to decipher.
In Pakistan's Karakoram, Nanga Parbat and Hindukush ranges, this melting is creating a ticking time bomb. The May 2022 Glacial Lake Outburst Flood (GLOF) in Hassanabad, Hunza, which destroyed homes and a critical bridge, was a mere precursor. Events in 2025 in Ghizer (GB) and Buner (KPK) signal an accelerating trend.
While projects like the UNDP's GLOF-II Project aim to install early warning systems, they are a palliative measure against a metastasizing problem. The need for comprehensive vulnerability assessments and nature-based solutions has never been more urgent.
Jhelum, Chenab, Ravi, Sutlej and Beas are not just rivers and waterways. They are the bedrock of civilization, ritual, and identity. They are the phenomenological essence of the sub-continent on both sides of the Radcliffe line.
The flood waters are severing our ties with those roots essential for our existence. In Indian Punjab, over 1312 villages are underwater and 26 are dead. In Pakistani Punjab, three transboundary rivers have swollen to great perils, affecting more than 2,300 villages, killing at least 33 and almost half a million people have been evacuated so far.
Residents wading through flooded roads are not just navigating water, they are also navigating their broken connection to the land that sustains them.
In Jammu and Kashmir from August 14, the series of cloudbursts continues. So far, 130 people are dead, 140 injured, and 32 pilgrims still missing. In fact, the figures are more, hitting Jammu city very hard.
An independent weather advisory warns that cloudbursts are possible in Himachal Pradesh and Jammu and Kashmir's Chenab Valley and Kashmir Valley until September 15.
In the upcoming winter, Jammu and Kashmir might even face an anomalous winter due to climatic shifts, neutral forecasts indicate high volatility, with potential for either a premature, abrupt onset or a significantly delayed seasonal transition, disrupting ecological phenology.
However, due to current floods, the submerged agriculture fields represent more than lost income; they represent the rupture of an agrarian telos that has defined this region for a millennium. The hope of farmers now drowns in the silt. The loss is profound involving fields, homes, schools, offices, shops and other properties.
Herein lies the brutal paradox, the central dialectic of this disaster. Cataclysmic events, with their raw humanistic maxim, possess a leveling power. They reduce humans to a state of bare life, striving for survival, shelter, and the safety of their kin. In this state, the artificiality of national borders is exposed by the absolute, indifferent geography of water.
Yet, as the trauma unfolds, this latent humanity is not getting to the surface. The huge trust deficit and latent enmity between New Delhi and Islamabad create a sociological force field that repels cooperation. The abeyance of river-sharing treaty unilaterally and the accusatory discourse over barrage failures are actions rooted in a defunct paradigm of absolute sovereignty and mutual suspicion.
This political reality creates a bizarre and tragic dissonance. Indifferent to man-made borders, flags and fences, water wreaks havoc indiscriminately, paralysing the mechanisms for shared mitigation, amplifying the common enemies of systemic poverty, collapsing healthcare, a declining happiness index, and rising food insecurity which are never addressed with the collective urgency they demand.
The suffering, thus, becomes balkanized, claimed by separate national narratives of resilience, rather than uniting people in a shared struggle for a habitable future. It is a failure of inter-subjective recognition on a colossal scale.
The immediate crisis is one of trauma and displacement, involving the morbidity of drowning, injury and loss. But the longer-term reality is a silent epidemic - the specter of waterborne diseases like cholera, typhoid, and dysentery.
The contamination of aquifers and water sources creates a secondary wave of suffering, a slow violence that attacks the body from within long after the visible flood has passed. This medical emergency disproportionately affects the most vulnerable, including the poor, the elderly, and children, deepening existing social inequities and stretching shattered public health systems to their breaking point.
Ecologically, the genesis of this crisis is clear. The dams raised in the Chenab valley, while totems of development, are implicated by ecologists in altering microclimates and exacerbating geological stresses. But the core driver is unequivocally climate change. The phenomenon of GLOFs across the Nanga Parbat, Karakoram, and Zanaskar range aren’t an exception. They are direct symptoms of a warming planet, creating a negative feedback loop of profound vulnerability.
The solution set must be as layered and complex as the problem analysis. The call for a "joint South Asia climate task force" is not a bureaucratic fantasy but a pragmatic necessity. The region needs a form of transnational governance for a transnational threat.
The advocacy for new techniques of rainwater harvesting, water conservation and raising of check dams over large-scale industrial projects like bigger dams speaks to a necessary philosophical shift towards decentralised, ecological harmony and watershed management over centralised, disruptive control. This is particularly critical for Pakistan as a lower riparian nation, whose water security is intrinsically tied to the hydrological practices of its upstream neighbor.
This is not merely an engineering challenge but a civilizational one. It demands a new epistemology that synthesizes traditional hydronomic knowledge with modern climate science. It requires an anthropological sensitivity to the cultural bonds between people and their environment. It needs a philosophical courage, an ethical pivot, to see the other not as an enemy to be suspicious of, but as a co-inhabitant of a shared, fragile watershed.
The floods ravaging both sides of the LoC remind us that while borders may divide land, they cannot divide the atmosphere, the watershed, or the consequences. The water flowing from the melting glaciers does not recognize the Line of Control or any divide. It will nourish or destroy communities on both sides indiscriminately.
The choice is no longer whether to share the water, but whether to share a strategy for survival, or to separately succumb to a shared disaster. The deluge is the question. Cooperation, or its absence, will be the answer.
To put it poetically:
"The sky forgets its gentle art,
And tears the high Himalayas part.
The same grey deluge, blind and deep,
Has rocked the Punjab - both to sleep.
The Chenab swells, the Ravi screams,
And drowns the fabric of all dreams.
The same cold water, swift and grim,
Has made a nightmare’s bitter swim.
No flag can hold the rising tide,
No border keeps the fear inside.
The same dread grips the young and old,
The same fierce story must be told.
A neighbour’s cry, a stranger’s hand,
Is all that’s left of solid land.
The same hope in a rescued face,
The same slow trek to find a place.
The silt now claims the standing grain,
The fruit of patient sun and rain.
The same deep loss on either side,
The same dark, unforgiving ride.
The mist that shrouds the mountain’s brow,
Sees not the line we fight for now.
It feeds the same relentless springs,
The same destruction it brings.
Can we not see this common foe,
Is this shared and the elemental woe?
The water makes a single grave,
For the poor farmer; timid; the brave.
Let one drop fall, a sound so small,
Then hear the human answer call.
One hammer strike, one shared design,
To mend your broken world and mine.
Across the wall: beyond the wall
Have you liked the news article?